This is a post-election update. I've been thinking and wanted to record my thoughts before it all fades away. The big news:
We won!
The third posting of the Garfield County (CO) election office reports that 6B, the ballot measure to preserve library funding, garnered 13,968 votes -- more than twice as many as the votes against it.
Not only that, more people voted for the library than voted for or against any other candidate or issue on the ballot. It was a profound statement of support for a beloved institution.
Thanks due
- To the remarkable service-oriented staff of the Garfield County Public Library District. They have warm hearts and bright eyes.
- To Magellan Strategies, who conducted a survey last January on the viability of the proposal. They gave it a 67% chance of success. The final result was 66.8.
- To Jared Boigon of Team Civix for survey design, interpretation, and distillation of messages to what mattered.
- To the library board that voted unanimously to put the measure before the citizens.
- To Protect Our Garco Libraries which gathered so many signatures of support.
- To the many people who made videos in support of the campaign, or wrote letters to the editor, or handed out campaign information, or donated. Team Civix recommended a campaign budget of $25,000, mostly focused on postcard mailings with endorsements. We raised $15,000 from all across the county. So we had to match money to mailings, and did buy cheaper social media ads too. But the people who stepped up to do the videos were heartfelt, smart, and altogether charming. They reanged from an enthusiastic nine year old to a ninety year old long time resident. Both county commissioners candidates, Republican and Democrat, also made videos. All of them were local. And these videos, posted on Instagram and Facebook by Omfluence Marketing (a shout out to Marlene and Olivia), may have reached as people as anything else.
- To the Committee to Maintain Our Garfield County Libraries, including Jocelyn Durrance (Chair), Carole O’Brien (Campaign Agent), Kevin O’Brien (Treasurer), Ellen Dole, Sharon Morris, Laurie Raymond, and Jamie Tredeaux. I was a member, too.
- And of course to the voters of Garfield County, who just wanted to keep their libraries strong, and showed up to make it happen.
Lessons learned
I got to see up close what community organizing looks like. It's people learning how things work, talking about how it ought to work, then doing something to get there. I was part of a team of volunteers, all of whom brought something to the mix that proved essential.
I'm still a newcomer to the area, so my fellow committee members' depth of connections to their neighbors was essential. We all tackled things we hadn't done before, and put our hours and dollars in the pool. Good public work is like any other kind. It helps to be organized, to set hard deadlines that follow the law. It helps to be open to new information, but keep disciplined to the goal.
Incidentally, our early expenses (because they were the cheapest) were handouts. The good news: it helped us get a logo, and boil down the message to a small handout. I'm not sure if the handouts, mostly distributed outside our branches by volunteers, were effective in changing anyone's mind or recruiting new supporters. I don't think they were as convincing as some of the other methods listed below. But they did tell people that the library was on the ballot. And it helped to coalesce us as a team.
I also learned a few other things.
Don't respond to every attack
Our political strategist gave some clear and succinct advice. Don't respond to every attack. We already tested various messages in the survey. Library "opponents" were a small minority. So were their concerns. Why repeat their arguments? It's hard to capture anyone's attention. When you do, what do you want them to remember?
So naturally, someone raised an issue we hadn't tested. Didn't the library have a reserve of two years of operating costs? Isn't that enough money?
The test of the challenge was vetting the exposure. Was there some kind of mismanagement behind having a savings account? No. In fact, it was a mark of thoughtful planning. A few people mentioned it, but not very many. So we let it go.
Yard Signs
For candidates, yard signs are important. It's about name recognition. No one was running ads or posting signs against the library. The problem wasn't the cost. It was how to distribute them, a logistical issue. So we were cautious, trying to target high visibility spaces.
A note here that my successor as library director, Abraham Korah, had suggested making yard signs about library support back in 2024. "Libraries build communities." It was a positive, feel good thing. They kind of served as campaign signs, too. We had a good year or so of handing them out, and I saw a lot of them come election time. It reinforced support.
Grand Avenue in Glenwood Springs sees daily traffic of some 25,000 cars. When traffic is slow, people look around.
Driving along the road, I stopped at the house that had one of these generic library support yard signs. I had a 6B sign I wanted to put alongside it. No one was home, so I left the sign by the front door with a clipped handwritten note: "would you be willing to put this sign out too? If not, call or email and we'll pick it up." I don't know who lived there. But the next day, it was right on the edge of a long, slow commute from Parachute to Aspen, something to stare at both ways.
Again, I think the first sign built support for the second. But the second signs had a lot of reach.
Email lists
In response to an organization that a few years ago had gathered petitions demanding various censorship actions, library supporters also started a petition. This developed, through the Protect Our Garco Libraries citizens group, a core list of demonstrated supporters. We had almost 1,000 names. These eventually formed the core of our monthly newsletter updates.A second list was compiled from the library's community interviews (a process completed twice of talking to countywide leaders from across various sectors). Before the library board voted to put the issue on the ballot, the library sent out an informational email: the board was considering the issue, and here's where they could find more background. They had already come to see the library as a trustworthy partner. As a result of the library mailing, community movers and shakers all had at least one exposure to the issue.
Endorsements
Team CiviX recommended that our budget include mailing to the various areas including endorsements by local leaders. In fact, we could only afford one mailing, so we wound up listing endorsements from all over the county. Several of our committee members reached out to well-known names across the political spectrum, asking if we could list them as supporters on the mailing. Virtually everyone agreed.
Responding to censorship
In the resistance to censorship, several things are vital. It's important to have strong policies. It's important to have a director who understands and supports the value of intellectual freedom, and staff who have been well-trained about how best to respond to challenges. It's important to have a board that holds firm to its mission. And my big takeaway: none of those things is enough. Ultimately, the success of a public library depends upon the persistent cultivation of support across the whole community. As we saw in the recent blue wave (a strong rejection of a corrupt, incompetent, and increasingly authoritarian regime), we get the institutions we deserve, meaning the ones we stand up for. It can take time to develop that broad support. Libraries ignore it at their peril.If the measure had failed, the library would have lost $1 million a year. The survey correctly identified the message: we want to maintain services. The measure involved a previous mill levy sunsetting in 2027. Setting that question in front of the community was right and good. The fact that it was not a new tax was also good.
Finally, I am heartened and relieved. I've made great new friends in the community, and have learned a lot from them. More importantly, the library's financial well-being is now secure for the foreseeable future.
Comments